Where NFL's Rookie QBs Are Succeeding, Need Improvement

As the 2024 NFL season unfolds, the three starting rookie quarterbacks—Caleb Williams (No. 1 overall), Jayden Daniels (No. 2 overall), and Bo Nix (No. 12 overall)—have encountered significant challenges in their first two games, all notably failing to throw a single touchdown pass. Their performances have been marked by struggles, and this article examines early statistics and identifies key areas for improvement as they prepare for Week 3.

Caleb Williams (Chicago Bears) — No. 1 Overall

Despite a 1-1 record, Williams’ initial outings have been a mixed bag. After a lackluster win over the Tennessee Titans, the Bears faced a more difficult challenge against the Houston Texans, where Williams was sacked seven times. His Week 2 stats revealed a completion rate of 62.2% on 37 attempts, averaging just 4.7 yards per throw. He struggled significantly in the second half, throwing two interceptions and showcasing underthrows that led to turnovers.

To improve, Williams needs better protection from his offensive line, which has consistently struggled with stunts and pressure. He demonstrated moments of promise with impressive escapes from pressure but must learn to make quicker decisions and maintain composure in the pocket.

Jayden Daniels (Washington Commanders) - No. 2 Overall

Daniels has had the best rookie quarterback performance of his draft class, showing growth but remaining reliant on his legs, rushing for 44 yards in Week 2 while completing 79.3% of his passes. However, many of these completions were short throws, resulting in an average depth of target of just 5.0 yards. Despite this, his Week 2 performance was an improvement over the first game, contributing to the Commanders’ 425 total yards.

Going forward, Daniels needs to work on maintaining his field vision and looking for deeper targets, rather than defaulting to checkdowns. Enhancing his ability to go through progressions will be crucial as he continues to adapt to the league.

Bo Nix (Denver Broncos) - No. 12 Overall

Nix’s start has been challenging, with the Broncos at 0-2 and Nix throwing four interceptions without a touchdown. His Week 2 performance included 20 completions on 35 attempts for 246 yards, but he still lacks consistency. Although he showed flashes of potential with a few impressive throws, his overall accuracy was questionable, highlighted by interceptions showcasing a lapse in judgment.

For Nix, the key to improvement lies in reducing turnovers and increasing his completion rate on deeper throws. He must also work on making quicker decisions to mitigate pressure, as the Broncos’ offense struggles to find rhythm.

Conclusion

As these rookie quarterbacks continue to navigate their first NFL seasons, their early performances reveal both promise and areas needing improvement. With adjustments in offensive line protection for Williams, a more aggressive passing approach for Daniels, and reduced turnovers for Nix, each player has the potential to evolve and lead their teams as the season unfolds. Week 3 will be a pivotal moment for all three as they strive for their first touchdown passes and further establish their roles in the NFL.